Filosofômetro
Portrait of Alasdair MacIntyre
Communitarian · Contemporary

Alasdair MacIntyre

Archetype: Communitarian of Virtue

1929 to 2025 · Scotland and Notre Dame, USA

“I only know what to do if I know what story I am part of.”

Do you think like Alasdair MacIntyre? Answer 44 to 132 statements and find out who, among 130 thinkers, has the way of thinking closest to yours.

Who was Alasdair MacIntyre

A Scottish philosopher who settled in the United States and died in 2025 at 96. In After Virtue, he diagnosed modern morality as a set of fragments with no possible agreement. He proposed recovering Aristotle's ethics of virtue, lived within communities and traditions that give meaning to our choices.

Core ideas

  • Modern moral debate is fragmented because it has lost a shared idea of the good
  • Virtues are learned in practices and communities with a shared history
  • We understand our lives as a narrative tied to a larger tradition

The tradition: Communitarian

Communitarianism criticizes liberal individualism and highlights the role of community and tradition in moral formation. MacIntyre is one of its central names, though he disliked the label.

In the same tradition: Charles Taylor

Learn more: Wikipedia

Where Alasdair MacIntyre stands on the 11 axes

Each axis runs from the first pole (−1) to the second (+1). These are the positions the test compares with your answers.

Knowledge
ReasonExperience · +0.30Experience
Will
FateBalanced · +0.00Freedom
Meaning
Given meaningGiven meaning, strong · −0.70Created meaning
Ethics
DutyDuty · −0.50Consequences
Social life
IndividualCommunity, strong · +1.00Community
Happiness
PleasureVirtue, strong · +0.80Virtue
Reality
MatterSpirit · +0.30Spirit
Truth
CertaintyCertainty · −0.40Doubt
Change
TraditionTradition, strong · −0.70Rupture
Suffering
AcceptAccept · −0.20Resist
Power
AuthorityAuthority · −0.30Autonomy

Thinkers similar to Alasdair MacIntyre

Which philosopher
thinks like you?

Start the test